International surrogacy judgment reinforces need for early legal advice

October 16, 2026

A new Family Court judgment has reinforced the importance of taking specialist legal advice before entering into an illegal international surrogacy arrangement.

In D & Anor v K (Illegal Chinese Commercial Surrogacy) [2026] EWFC 279, Mr Justice MacDonald granted a parental order in respect of a child born following an illegal commercial surrogacy arrangement in China, while strongly criticising the lack of due diligence carried out before the arrangement was entered into.

The intended parents had entered into the arrangement without knowing that surrogacy is prohibited in China. The surrogate had not received legal advice and there were also difficulties surrounding the documentation, payments made under the arrangement and establishing the surrogate’s legal status.

Although the Court concluded that making a parental order was in the child’s best interests, Mr Justice MacDonald at paragraph 64 of his judgment stated:

“Would-be parents who are contemplating entering into a commercial foreign surrogacy arrangement should be in no doubt that the court will not make a parental order simply because the court is presented with an apparent fait accompli based on the fact that the child is already in the care of the intended parents.”

The decision should not be seen as a licence to enter into unlawful commercial surrogacy arrangements overseas.

The judgment repeats guidance from earlier international surrogacy cases and stresses the importance of intended parents obtaining advice from a specialist solicitor before embarking on a surrogacy arrangement involving another country.

It sets out a series of questions which should be considered at the outset, including whether surrogacy is permitted in the country concerned; who will be recognised as the child’s legal parents at birth; the legal status of the surrogate and, where relevant, her spouse; the role of any surrogacy agency; the information and support provided to the surrogate; arrangements for contact; the child’s nationality; and the steps required to enable the child to travel to and enter the UK.

The guidance also highlights the need to consider immigration advice, estate planning and arrangements for the child’s care and financial security in the event of the incapacity or death of an intended parent.

Commenting on the judgment, Clare Porter-Phillips from Exchange Chambers said:

“This judgment is a clear reminder of why specialist legal advice needs to be taken before an international surrogacy arrangement is entered into.

“There can be very different legal regimes in different countries. Intended parents need to know whether surrogacy is permitted, who will be recognised as the child’s legal parents, what the legal position of the surrogate is and what will need to happen after the child is born.

“The questions set out by the Court provide a useful checklist of the issues that need to be addressed before proceeding. Establishing the answers at the outset can avoid serious difficulties further down the line.

“The court also makes clear that a parental order should not be regarded as automatic simply because a child has been born and is already living with the intended parents. The circumstances surrounding an international surrogacy arrangement will be carefully scrutinised.”

Joanne Barnett from Exchange Chambers added:

“For anyone considering international surrogacy, the message is clear – be aware and be fully informed. In this case, the court’s decision fell on the side of the would-be parent and whilst the court deprecated the course taken by the applicants by entering into an illegal commercial surrogacy arrangement, it ultimately concluded that the case could not be said to be the clearest case of an abuse of public policy and made the parental order. Other would-be parents’ cases could be seen in a different light, with devastating consequences for all.”

Joanne added:

“Please get the specialist advice required beforehand, as many illegal international surrogacy agencies deliberately do not inform either the surrogate or would-be parents about the illegalities and consequences of proceeding with the arrangement. I understand the need and drive to have a child, but would-be parents must prevent the most devastating consequences occurring, especially where the court could determine that they will not make a parental order or worse, that you have been involved in an illegal international surrogacy arrangement.”

At the International Jersey Conference last week (October 2026), delegates heard from Sir Andrew MacFarlane that there was a need for the government to tighten up the law in this area to prevent exploitation of both the surrogate and the would-be parent in illegal international surrogacy arrangements.

The full judgment can be viewed here:

D & Anor v K (Illegal Chinese Commercial Surrogacy) – Find Case Law – The National Archives